x

Starting early is the best way to ensure success!

clayborneUpdated

Green Time vs Screen Time: The Benefits of Outdoor Learning

Written By: Lee Elberson - CEO

It might sound strange coming from the CEO of a tutoring company, but here it is: one of the best things you can do for your child’s grades this week has nothing to do with a textbook. Send them outside. That’s where the research on green time vs. screen time keeps pointing.

Earlier this month I joined Adam Hawes on WINA’s Cville Right Now with my friend Amy Lastinger, who teaches outdoor education to kindergarten through 4th graders at Peabody School. Amy brought the view from the forest floor. I brought the research. And the research lines up behind one idea:

Green time isn’t a break from learning. It’s fuel for it.

Here’s what that means for your family.

Time outside makes time inside work better

A common worry from teachers is that kids come back from outside too wound up to focus. The research says the opposite.

Researchers at the University of Illinois gave third graders matched pairs of lessons: same teacher, same topic, one taught outside and one taught inside. After the outdoor lesson, teachers could teach almost twice as long before they had to stop and redirect a student. That held even for the teacher who expected outdoor lessons to backfire.

Lessons outside boost focus inside After an indoor lesson, teachers taught 3.5 minutes before redirecting a student. After an outdoor lesson, 6.5 minutes, almost twice as long. A lesson outside buys focus inside Teaching time before a student had to be redirected, 3rd grade 3.5 min after an indoor lesson → 6.5 min after an outdoor lesson = ~2x uninterrupted teaching time
Source: Kuo, Browning & Penner, Frontiers in Psychology, 2018.

Other studies point the same way. A small study of children with ADHD found a 20-minute walk in a park improved concentration about as much as common medications. And in a study of about 2,600 schoolchildren in Barcelona, kids at greener schools showed faster growth in working memory over a year. Those two are smaller or correlational, so treat them as promising rather than proven, but the direction is consistent.

It’s an eyesight story, too

This is the one that surprises parents. Nearsightedness in children has been climbing, and time outdoors appears to be one of the best defenses. In a randomized trial in China, schools that added 40 minutes of outdoor time to the school day saw 23% fewer children become nearsighted over three years. Because it was a true experiment, this is cause and effect, not just correlation.

Outdoor time and nearsightedness About 40 percent of children on a usual school day became nearsighted within three years, compared with 30 percent of children who got 40 extra minutes outdoors each day, a 23 percent lower risk. 40 extra minutes outside, every school day Randomized trial, about 1,900 first graders, followed for 3 years 40% became nearsighted usual school day vs 30% became nearsighted +40 min outdoors daily = 23% lower risk of nearsightedness
Source: He et al., JAMA, 2015 (Guangzhou, China). Rates rounded: 39.5% vs. 30.4%.

My physics background makes me love the likely explanation. Daylight is many times brighter than classroom light, and that brightness appears to slow the eye growth that causes nearsightedness. A study of more than 4,000 children in Sydney found that it was outdoor time that mattered, not sport: indoor sports didn’t help at all.

Replace screens, don’t just remove them

A review of 186 studies found that screen time and green time pull kids’ wellbeing in opposite directions. There’s even early evidence that green time can buffer some of the effects of heavy screen use.

Screen time and green time High screen time is linked with depression, anxiety and stress, and poorer self-regulation. Green time is linked with better attention and memory, resilience and self-esteem, and better grades. Screen time and green time pull in opposite directions A review of 186 studies on kids and teens High screen time linked with Depression Anxiety and stress Poorer self-regulation ↔ Green time linked with Better attention and memory Resilience and self-esteem Better grades
Source: Oswald et al., PLOS ONE, 2020. These are associations, not proof of cause.

Here’s where my coaching philosophy comes in. I believe in systems over discipline. If you take the phone away and leave a hole, the phone wins. The fix isn’t more willpower. It’s a better option.

You can’t just take the phone away. You have to give kids somewhere better to be.

What this looks like in a real school: Forest Fridays

Amy has built exactly that “somewhere better.” Every Friday, rain or shine, all year long, her students head outside as field scientists. They keep notebooks with the date, time, temperature, weather, and what they observe, and they return to the same spots to see what has changed. Then they ask the most important question in science: what do you wonder?

Each student starts with a sit spot, and Amy’s instructions for it are my favorite three sentences from the whole conversation:

“Slow down. Get quiet. Get bored.”

Boredom is exactly the moment kids usually reach for a phone. Amy teaches them to sit through it, and that’s when the curiosity shows up. One of her students put it better than I could: “If you say you don’t see anything interesting, you’re lying. There is always something… Just look closer.”

Amy’s students have since taken that curiosity public. Through the Piedmont Prairie Project, they’re helping restore a tallgrass prairie at Darden Towe Park using local native plants. Less than 1% of Virginia’s native Piedmont prairies remain, and the students built the project website themselves.

Is soccer practice enough?

This was the question I most wanted to answer. Lots of kids are outside at practice several nights a week. Does that count? For some benefits, yes. For others, not really.

Is soccer practice enough? What organized outdoor sports deliver compared with free outdoor time. Eyesight: yes. Mood and self-esteem: mostly. Attention reset: less. Independence: no. Lifelong habits: weaker. Does organized sport count as green time? What outdoor sports deliver, compared with free, unstructured time outside Eyesight Yes Daylight protects. Indoor sports don’t. Mood and self-esteem Mostly Even 5 minutes of green exercise helps. Attention reset Less Games demand focus. Nature lets it rest. Independence No Kids grow when they run their own time. Lifelong habits Weaker Free nature play before 11 predicts them.
Sources: Rose et al., Ophthalmology, 2008; Barton & Pretty, 2010; Barker et al., 2014; Wells & Lekies, 2006. “Attention reset” reflects Attention Restoration Theory rather than a head-to-head study.

Daylight protects eyes whether a child is at practice or poking at a creek, and even five minutes of exercise in green space gives a measurable lift to mood and self-esteem. But a game with a coach, plays, and a scoreboard asks a lot of a child’s attention, while the restorative kind of outdoor time asks for nothing. And independence comes from kids running their own time. A University of Colorado study of six-year-olds found that more unstructured time went with a better ability to set and reach their own goals. That’s exactly the skill we teach in study skills coaching.

Are kids just overscheduled?

I want to be fair here, because I run a business that sells structured time. The largest study on so-called overscheduling, covering about 5,000 families, found that most teens spend about five hours a week in organized activities, and kids in activities generally do better than kids in none. Activities aren’t the villain.

The problem isn’t the soccer practice. It’s when every hour has a grown-up in charge of it.

The sweet spot is the pickup game in the park: it’s outside, and the kids run it.

The long game

The longest-range evidence comes from Denmark, where researchers tracked about 900,000 people from childhood into adulthood.

Green space in childhood and adult mental health Among about 900,000 people in Denmark, those who grew up with the least green space had up to 55 percent higher risk of psychiatric disorders as adults. More years near green space meant lower risk. A green childhood pays off for decades About 900,000 people tracked in Denmark 55% higher risk, at most Kids who grew up with the least green space had up to 55% higher risk of psychiatric disorders as adults. More years near green space, lower risk.
Source: Engemann et al., PNAS, 2019. An association across a huge population, not proof of cause.

That’s an association rather than proof of cause, but it’s an enormous sample, and it fits everything else we know. A Cornell study adds a twist: free, “wild” play in nature before age 11, like hiking or playing in the woods, shaped lifelong habits. Mandatory programs didn’t. Unstructured beats scheduled.

What to do this week

You don’t need a forest behind your house. Concretely:

  • Make outside the warm-up, not the reward. Twenty minutes outdoors before homework, not after it.
  • For high schoolers, build it into the study plan. Study for 45 minutes, walk outside for 15, then get back to it. Scrolling isn’t rest; a walk outside is.
  • Protect one empty afternoon. One afternoon a week with nothing on the calendar.
  • Pick a weekend spot and leave the phones in the car. Try Ivy Creek Natural Area, Wildrock in Crozet, a walk on the Rivanna Trail, or the prairie at Darden Towe Park.
  • Give your kid a sit spot. Amy’s idea, and an easy one to steal: one spot outside where they go to slow down, get quiet, and get bored.

Here’s the bottom line:

Focus is a skill, and the outdoors is one of the best places to build it. Get them outside, let them get a little bored, and watch what they notice.

A big thank you to Amy Lastinger for joining me, and to Adam Hawes for having us.

Is your student struggling to focus?

Focus, follow-through, and time management are skills, and our study skills coaches teach them every day. Start with a free consultation, and we’ll build a personalized plan around your student’s goals, schedule, and yes, some green time.

Get Started

Frequently asked questions

Does time outside help kids focus in school?

Yes. In a matched-lesson study of third graders, teachers could teach almost twice as long without interruption after a lesson outdoors. A small study of children with ADHD found a 20-minute walk in a park improved concentration about as much as common medications.

Can time outdoors prevent nearsightedness?

It appears to help. In a randomized trial, adding 40 minutes of outdoor time to the school day cut the share of children who became nearsighted over three years by about 23%. Researchers believe bright daylight is the key, which is why indoor sports don’t offer the same protection.

Do organized outdoor sports count as green time?

Partly. Outdoor practice delivers the daylight and much of the mood benefit. Free, unstructured time outdoors adds what sports usually don’t: a mental reset and the chance for kids to run their own time.

How much time outside do kids need?

There’s no single magic number, but small doses count. Five minutes of green exercise measurably lifts mood, 20 minutes in a park improves attention, and 40 extra minutes a day was enough to reduce nearsightedness. A daily outdoor habit matters more than an occasional big outing.

Sources

©2026 Clayborne Education. All Rights Reserved.